Our Environmental Crusades Are More Fashions Than Science

0


Recently I met a woman who wholly subscribed to the climate-change agenda. (Such people are a dime a dozen in my region.) She explained that she and her husband had moved back up North from Tennessee. And that state, she said, wasn’t as warm as she expected. In fact, this woman, well into her 60s, stated that she didn’t know its weather wasn’t like Florida’s. In other words:

She didn’t grasp the obvious and profound difference between Tennessee’s and Florida’s climates.

But she still felt qualified to judge the differences between the Earth’s climate over eons and what it is today — and that our current climate isn’t what it should be.

This lady isn’t alone in forming such ill-considered opinions, either. Many millions do this despite not grasping the facts or the science because they have something else: the fashions. The environmental fashions have been many, too, and have come and gone, as fashions will do.

Addressing this Friday, commentator Bill Ponton writes:

The best way to convey the progression and evolution of these movements is to list them in chronological order. They all owe their start to the Grand Daddy of them all, radioactive fallout. It was the start of our societal obsession with environmental poisoning that has continued over 75 years.

Here is part of Ponton’s list (it’s very long, but can be read in its entirety here).

1950 Radioactive fallout

1956 Mercury poisoning

1960 Air pollution and smog

1962 Pesticides and DDT

1965 Worldwide food shortages

1968 The population bomb

… 2012 Climate tipping points

2015 Dangerous warming beyond 1.5–2°C

2016 Plastic pollution in the oceans

2018 Climate emergency

2019 Species loss

2021 Climate-related food insecurity and migration

2022 Forever chemicals (PFAS)

2024 Planetary ecological crisis

Ponton then writes that all “these fears are either baseless or have a small grain of truth associated with them.” Now, I don’t think I’d go quite that far. For example, species are lost due to man’s actions (though the statistics on this may be exaggerated). And ocean-going plastic waste is a problem, one I wrote about decades ago. Yet this brings us to an important point: Actual imperatives can be ignored when fashions hold sway.

Tree-huggers No More

When speaking of “fashions” in their primary sense (apparel), they can be ridiculous, as illustrated in the video here. Clothing can have cultural effects, too (e.g., immodest dress’ stoking of lust). But fashions in scientific priorities can be far more devastating still.

When prioritizing greentopian climate-change policies, for instance, there can be billions in economic impact. They can, however, also have environmental effects.

Just consider calculated deforestation. Not-so-green greentopians the world over have destroyed forests in “zero-carbon energy’s” name. Examples:

  • The Central Maine Power (CMP) corridor — enables the transfer of ostensibly “clean” green energy from Quebec, Canada, to Massachusetts. The project, however, involved destroying tens of thousands of trees in the largest U.S. forest east of the Mississippi. This created a North Maine Woods “corridor” 145 miles long, 53 miles of which had been unbroken forest. This is, too, all so that, as a critic put it, Maine can be “someone else’s extension cord.”
  • Then there is what’s known as “Grimm’s fairy tale forest” — the pre-Columbian Reinhardswald State Forest in Germany — which faced a grim fate. In this place, home to 600-year-old oaks and beech trees that have seen four centuries, approximately 10,000 trees were destroyed. And why? To make room for a wind farm — which will no doubt be obsolete in a decade or two.
  • In addition, there was the swath of Amazon rainforest bulldozed last year, a project that also claimed tens of thousands of trees. The reason? You can’t make this up: to host an environmentalist affair — the COP30 climate conference.

There are many other examples of greentopian forest destruction, too (click here).

Would You Buy a Used Prediction From These Guys?

The irony here is that, as I’m old enough to remember (unfortunately), saving forest was once an environmentalist priority. In the early ’70s, for example, transitioning away from paper supermarket bags (then the norm) became an imperative. We were cutting down too many trees, we were warned. And while this threat was probably overblown, at least it reflects more realistic priorities. Preserving forests is, after all, something real. Our environment is nicer when there are more green spaces than when there are fewer green spaces. It’s not a supposed threat that, we’re warned, lies 60 years down the road.

“But wait,” some will say, “what of the predictions of climatic doom?” Well, before considering them gospel, consider greentopians’ track record. As the late Dr. Walter E. Williams wrote in “Environmentalists’ Wild Predictions” in 2008, environmentalist Nigel Calder once

warned, “The threat of a new ice age must now stand alongside nuclear war as a likely source of wholesale death and misery for mankind.” C.C. Wallen of the World Meteorological Organization said, “The cooling since 1940 has been large enough and consistent enough that it will not soon be reversed.” In 1968, Professor Paul Ehrlich, Vice President [Al] Gore’s hero and mentor, predicted there would be a major food shortage in the U.S. and “in the 1970s … hundreds of millions of people are going to starve to death.” Ehrlich forecasted that 65 million Americans would die of starvation between 1980 and 1989, and by 1999 the U.S. population would have declined to 22.6 million. Ehrlich’s predictions about England were gloomier: “If I were a gambler, I would take even money that England will not exist in the year 2000.”

By the way, the one sustainability-related wager Ehrlich did make, he lost. He bet economist Julian Simon in 1980 that the inflation-adjusted prices of five metals selected by Ehrlich would rise by 1990 due to population increase. The prices dropped, and Ehrlich had to send Simon a check for about $576.

Unfortunately, though, greentopian doomsayers’ playing on environmentalist fashions costs the rest of us a lot more than that.



Source
Las Vegas News Magazine

Leave A Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Are you human? Please solve:Captcha


This website uses cookies to improve your experience. We'll assume you're ok with this, but you can opt-out if you wish. Accept Read More