How Party Politics Destroys Independent Thought and Liberty
“Nothing is more dangerous to the cause of truth and liberty than a party-spirit.”
Noah Webster didn’t mince words.
Over 200 years ago, he saw the warning signs we still ignore today – the danger of trading truth and principle for party loyalty.
This isn’t just some abstract warning. It’s a direct hit on the rot that dominates American politics today. When people stop thinking and start following, liberty doesn’t stand a chance.
Let’s walk through Webster’s message. Piece by piece and step by step.
Step One: Independence Is Surrendered.
“When men become members of a political club, they lose their individual independence of mind;”
Once someone attaches to a political tribe, the mind no longer operates freely. Every issue is filtered through “the cause,” which really means the people pulling the strings.
“They lose their impartiality of thinking and acting; and become the dupes of other men.”
Step 2: Fair judgment disappears.
Honest thinking vanishes. No longer guided by principle, the party faithful become pawns – moved by the loudest and most powerful voices, manipulated by those in control.
“The moment a man is attached to a club, his mind is not free:”
This is the foundation of the warning. If the mind isn’t free, the person isn’t either. Obedience replaces curiosity. Conformity replaces conviction.
Step 3: Tribalism replaces reason.
“He receives a bias from the opinions of the party:”
Suddenly, positions change. What was once wrong becomes right – because the party line says so.
“A question indifferent to him, is no longer indifferent, when it materially effects a brother of the society.”
Tribal politics hijack priorities. Issues that were once irrelevant become flashpoints – not because of principle, but because the party has something to gain.
“He is not left to act for himself; he is bound in honor to take part with the society – ”
The language of “honor” masks the reality of pressure. Dissent is disloyalty. Acting from conscience is frowned upon. Silence becomes complicity.
“his pride and his prejudices, if at war with his opinion, will commonly obtain the victory;”
Even when there’s inner conflict – when something feels off – pride usually wins. Staying in good standing outweighs standing for what’s right.
“and rather than incur the ridicule or censure of his associates, he will countenance their measures, at all hazards;”
Avoiding shame becomes the goal. To keep status and favor, people go along – supporting policies and actions they’d never accept from the other side.
“and thus an independant freeman is converted into a mere walking machine, a convenient engine of party leaders.”
Step 4: A Once-Free Mind Becomes An Obedient Tool.
No different from a campaign sign or a soundbite. Reliable, predictable – and utterly controlled.
That’s what party loyalty creates: blind obedience packaged as virtue.
Webster didn’t stop there.
“Nothing is more dangerous to the cause of truth and liberty than a party-spirit.”
Not foreign enemies. Not economic collapse. Not even war.
Party-spirit.
Truth is the Casualty
Because when winning becomes the goal, truth is the casualty. And when loyalty to a party overrides loyalty to liberty, the Constitution becomes optional. Power is excused. Abuse is rationalized.
This corruption isn’t limited to one side. It infects every corner of the political establishment – and most of the grassroots – today.
The loudest defenders of “freedom” often vanish when their team is the one in power. The same people who scream about overreach look the other way when it’s coming from their side.
“Follow the Constitution” becomes a slogan, not a standard.
“An independant freeman is converted into a mere walking machine, a convenient engine of party leaders.”
Webster’s warning still hits like a hammer.
It wasn’t just about politicians. It was about everyone willing to trade principle for party.
Those whose principles shift depending on which party is doing it were never patriots.
They’re pawns.
And nothing is more dangerous to liberty than letting pawns pretend they stand for freedom.
Latest posts by Michael Boldin (see all)